What can I substitute for the peanut butter for this recipe? Any ideas?

[aa12x]

Melted chocolate

 

[melsako]

Just google no peanutbutter muddy buddies .. theres several different varieties out there.. made some today without the peanut butter.. they are ok i guess but only batch i will make that way... made it due to family members with peanut allergies

 

[cassiabr]

Almond or cashew butter

 

[tzaousios]

@cassiabr I think there is a nut allergy.

 

[ohsleeperkj]

I’d substitute the peanut butter with Nutella, but if you’re substituting because of a peanut allergy, then you could melt butterscotch chips and use that in place of the peanut butter.

 

[saoshyant]

@plopster

 

[nelsontai]

I've made them by just skipping the peanut butter.

 

[thehelpedone]

Sun butter

 

[emojigirl]

Sunflower butter, Nutella, or cake icing

 

[cops4christ]

@iceboulevard93

 

[wolf911]

I've used melted almond bark

 

[bso66]

Nutella?

 

[jurisdoctor]

Another nut butter?

 

[walton]

Sun butter for sure. We used it at school In place of peanut butter

 

[mymondaymap]

Marshmallow fluff tasted great Place a small quantity of Fluff in a bowl, then slowly add warm water while mixing with a fork. Or, place 4 heaping tablespoons of Fluff and 3 tablespoons of water in a microwave-safe container, then microwave on high for 15 seconds. Remove and stir personally I added some melted butter and less water in

 

[leekonghian]

@herns

 

[herns]

@leekonghian definitely will make some for work

 

[roshnirajesh]

@kingoftheinternet

 

[suthrnbell]

@shauns552

 

[froze]

This tastes similar to peanut butter.