Seeking the Ultimate Mashed Potatoes Recipe for Thanksgiving – Share Your Best!

[lunacy]

Make ahead potatoes ...sour cream, cream cheese butter. Top with pepper and season salt

 

[truckingalongforgod]

I put alot of things depends on what is available. I never have used heavy creme not even sure what it is. But I put mayonnaise, to use less butter. It's so expensive and we use alot of butter. If I have sour creme I'll add it if I have creme cheese ill add some of that also. Salt and pepper of course. Then I taste see what else I need more of. And it's usually salt or pepper.

 

[rebeccac777]

Celery seed, whole milk, butter, cream cheese and a decent amount of sour cream!! And salt n pepper of course!

 

[lizzy212]

Red potatoes unpeeled, butter, shredded cheese, milk, ranch dressing and green onions chopped salt n pepper.

 

[doogles]

@lizzy212 yaaa ranch dressing. This is how I make mine

 

[splinterxa]

Do not over mix! They will get starchy and dry. Best to use a hand masher.
Butter, milk, sour cream and salt.

 

[justineflake]

Search Pioneer Woman Mashed Potatoes

 

[kirkstaller]

I use sour cream, butter, and cream cheese. So yummy!

 

[davestarr99]

Boil your potatoes with cloves of garlic (to your liking). Mash them with sour cream, butter, and some salt/pepper.

 

[hawke213x]

Butter milk garlic powder garlic salt fresh garlic salt and pepper

 

[gfbirch]

The Today Show / Honda& Jenna just had a great make ahead casserole like one today.

 

[asd963]

Yukon Gold potatoes. Start with those, peel and chop, boil in water with a pinch of salt under tender. Drain thoroughly, throw back into your pot with: Real Butter, Half and Half, Coarse* black pepper, 1/2 teaspoon salt, some chopped chives, and some sour cream. After you mash them, grease a baking dish. Preheat your oven to 375 degrees. Now comes my mom's secret: Add 1 beaten egg to the mashed potatoes. Mix together, pour into the baking dish and slide into the oven for about 25 minutes or until the top becomes a light golden brown.

 

[anaperez]

Martha Stewart has the best recipe which I’m requested to bring everywhere.

 

[childofthelord]

Butter
Heavy cream
(Roasted garlic is GREAT in there, too!)
Sometimes…
Butter
Sour cream or cream cheese
Shredded cheese
Diced scallions
Crispy bacon

 

[peterny]

Use a potaoe ricer!

 

[mrmccoy456]

substitute cream cheese for the milk

 

[skeptik76]

Pioneer woman mashed potatoes

 

[dooks]

Lots of butter garlic shallots salt and cream pr sour cream I've used both and love both of them

 

[tannerdude28]

Simmer raw cut up Yukon gold potatoes in milk until fork tender. Add a stick of butter, salt n pepper, mash and enjoy!

 

[tannerdude28]

Also, rinse them before you cut, not after!